EDI Comparison
Verify before you start
Compare with real numbers first
Most buyers are not ready to buy on the first visit. Start with a free tool or requirement check — then trial when you are ready.
Comparison
| Feature | ✦ SignalEDI | Orderful Pixel |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | ✓Seasonal from $99 — no per-partner fees | ✗$189/mo per trading partner |
| Cost at 2+ partners | ✓Starter covers up to 5 @ $199; unlimited on Growth ($999) | ✗Scales up with each partner |
| Setup Fee | ✓$0 | None advertised |
| Healthcare EDI | ✓Built-in (837/835/270/271) | ✗No healthcare X12 advertised |
| REST API access | ✓Included on all plans | ✗Web forms only (API is Mosaic) |
| Transport channels | ✓REST API, SFTP, AS2, web, email | ✗Web portal only |
| ERP integration | ✓Connectors (QuickBooks 1-click, SAP/NetSuite add-ons) | ✗Upgrade to Mosaic required |
| Document types | ✓850/855/856/810/997/999 + EDIFACT | ✗850 / 856 / 810 (retail) |
| Contract Length | ✓Month-to-month | No contracts |
| Pre-connected partner network | ✓Guided onboarding + partner packs | 10,000+ pre-connected partners |
| Retailer shipping labels | ✓Not a built-in feature | Carton/pallet labels, 12+ formats |
Why Teams Switch
Orderful Pixel charges roughly $189/mo per trading partner, so your bill climbs with every retailer you add. SignalEDI publishes flat monthly tiers with no per-partner fees — Starter at $199/mo (up to 5 partners) and unlimited partners on Growth ($999) — so multi-retailer programs stay predictable.
Orderful Pixel is a retail and supply-chain product and does not advertise healthcare X12 support. SignalEDI provides a path to evaluate 837, 835, and 270/271 workflows; Production PHI requires an executed BAA plus the HIPAA/BAA add-on ($199/mo; included on Enterprise).
Pixel is web-forms only; to get an API or ERP connection on Orderful you graduate to their separate Mosaic product. SignalEDI includes a REST API, SFTP, and AS2 in the same plan you start on.
Signal adds 855 acknowledgments, auto-generated 997/999, ASN readiness checks, downloadable reports, and confidence-gated recovery guidance on top of the PO-to-invoice flow.
Orderful Mosaic
| Feature | ✦ SignalEDI | Orderful Mosaic |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing transparency | ✓Published $199–$1999/mo | ✗Quote-based (no public price) |
| Target fit | ✓SMBs, often pre-ERP | ✗Complex supply chains + modern ERP |
| Healthcare EDI | ✓Included (837/835/270/271) | ✗Order-to-cash focus; no healthcare X12 advertised |
| Transport channels | ✓REST API, SFTP, AS2, web | ✗REST API + ERP connectors |
| Getting started | ✓Self-serve trial, month-to-month | ✗ERP integration, sales-led |
| ERP connectors | ✓QuickBooks 1-click, SAP/NetSuite add-ons | SAP/NetSuite/Dynamics/Infor native |
| Mapping automation | ✓AI-assisted mapping + auto-correct | Network-normalized, eliminates mapping |
| Pre-connected network | ✓Guided onboarding + partner packs | 10,000+ adaptive network |
Where Mosaic leads, we say so. Its network-normalized mapping (“connect once, trade with anyone”) and 10,000+ adaptive partner network are ahead of our AI-assisted mapping today. SignalEDI's edge is published flat pricing, a governed healthcare production path, and AS2/SFTP transport, with no ERP project or sales process required to start.
Try the parser
Load a sample 850, 856, or 810 and validate in-memory before you sign up. Sandbox only — nothing is stored.
Signal result
Score 100/100 · Purchase order · 9 segments
What Signal checked in this sandbox run.
Sample payload received in a sandbox-only validation context.
9 X12 segments detected.
Envelope and segment rules passed for demo validation.
997 accepted
Retailer simulation confirms the file is ready for AS2/SFTP test exchange.
Signal Fix suggestions
No blocking auto-fix suggestions for this sample.
Cost at scale
| Partners | ✦ SignalEDI (flat) | Orderful Pixel (est.) | Orderful Mosaic (est.) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 partner | ✓Seasonal $99/mo (Starter $199/mo year-round) | ≈ $189/mo | from ≈ $399/mo |
| 3 partners | ✓Seasonal $99/mo or Starter $199/mo | ≈ $567/mo | from ≈ $1,197/mo |
| 5 partners | ✓Starter $199/mo | ≈ $945/mo | from ≈ $1,995/mo |
| 10 partners | ✓Growth $999/mo (unlimited partners) | ≈ $1,890/mo | from ≈ $3,990/mo |
Pixel math: partners × ≈$189/mo. Mosaic math: partners × from ≈$399/mo (enterprise is custom, quote-based). SignalEDI fit: Seasonal $99/mo covers up to 3 partners for intermittent programs; Starter $199/mo covers up to 5 year-round; Growth $999/mo covers unlimited partners. Review current plan entitlements on pricing.
Honest pick
One trading partner, a need for the fastest first connection through a 10,000+ pre-connected network, or built-in retailer carton and pallet labels. If labels and network effects decide the purchase, Pixel is the honest pick.
Two or more trading partners (flat tiers beat per-partner billing), healthcare X12 on the same plan, or API/SFTP/AS2 transport without graduating to a separate product. Multi-retailer programs stay predictable on Starter $199/mo through five partners and Growth $999/mo beyond that.
Orderful prices per trading partner. Pixel, their web-EDI product, runs about $189/mo per trading partner, so the bill climbs with every retailer you add. Mosaic, their integrated/API product, is quote-based and starts higher (around $399/mo per partner; enterprise is custom). SignalEDI takes the opposite approach: published flat tiers with no per-partner fees — Starter $199/mo (up to 5 partners) and unlimited partners on Growth ($999) — with no setup fees and no per-document charges, so multi-retailer programs stay predictable.
Yes — but only in Mosaic. Orderful's Pixel tier is web forms only, so teams that need programmatic integration have to upgrade to the separate Mosaic product to get API access. SignalEDI includes a REST API on every plan, along with SFTP and AS2 transport, so you don't graduate to a different product (or price tier) to integrate EDI with your own systems.
Next step
Published monthly plans from Seasonal $99/mo with no per-partner fees — unlimited partners on Growth ($999) — plus a REST API, SFTP/AS2, and healthcare EDI included, with no sales call required.
FAQ
Orderful publishes per-trading-partner pricing. Pixel, their web-EDI product, is about $189/mo per trading partner, and Mosaic, their integrated/API product, starts around $399/mo per trading partner (enterprise is custom, quote-based). Because the fee repeats per partner, 10 active partners runs roughly $1,890–$3,990+/mo in base fees. SignalEDI publishes flat tiers instead — Starter $199/mo (up to 5 partners) and unlimited partners on Growth ($999) — with no per-partner fees.
Using Orderful's public per-partner figures (Pixel about $189/mo, Mosaic from about $399/mo, as of the June 2026 research date noted above): 1 partner runs about $189/mo on Pixel or from about $399/mo on Mosaic, versus SignalEDI Seasonal $99/mo or Starter $199/mo year-round. At 3 partners Pixel is about $567/mo while SignalEDI stays at Seasonal $99/mo (3-partner limit) or Starter $199/mo. At 5 partners Pixel is about $945/mo versus Starter $199/mo. At 10 partners Pixel is about $1,890/mo (Mosaic from about $3,990/mo) versus Growth $999/mo with unlimited partners. Confirm current Orderful pricing on their site before committing.
Orderful's API lives in Mosaic, their integrated/API product — Pixel (the web-EDI tier) is web forms only, so getting an API on Orderful means upgrading to Mosaic. SignalEDI includes a REST API on every plan, alongside SFTP and AS2, with no separate API product or upgrade required.
For lean teams without an in-house EDI department, you'll usually be evaluating Orderful Pixel, their web-EDI product. SignalEDI competes there on flat pricing, breadth, and healthcare. Mosaic is Orderful's separate API/ERP product you'd upgrade into; SignalEDI includes a REST API and SFTP/AS2 in your starting plan instead.
Pixel is priced per trading partner (about $189/mo each), so at one retailer it's roughly comparable to SignalEDI Starter ($199/mo). From your second retailer onward Pixel scales while SignalEDI stays flat through five partners on Starter — and unlimited partners on Growth ($999) keep multi-retailer TCO predictable as the partner list grows.
Two things, honestly: Orderful has a large pre-connected partner network (10,000+ trading partners) that can speed first connections, and Pixel generates retailer-formatted carton and pallet shipping labels built in. SignalEDI uses guided onboarding with partner packs and is not a label-printing tool today.
Yes, and more. Pixel covers purchase orders, ship notices, and invoices (850/856/810). SignalEDI covers those plus 855 acknowledgments, 997/999, EDIFACT, and healthcare X12 (837/835/270/271).
For the right buyer, yes. Mosaic targets complex supply chains with a modern ERP and uses quote-based pricing. SignalEDI fits teams that want published flat pricing, healthcare X12, and AS2/SFTP transport without an ERP project to get started. We don't claim to match Mosaic's network-normalized auto-mapping, but most SMBs don't need an enterprise ERP integration to become partner-ready.
Pixel wins when you trade with one partner, value a 10,000+ pre-connected partner network for faster first connections, or need built-in retailer carton and pallet shipping labels — two areas where Pixel leads and SignalEDI says so openly.
SignalEDI wins from the second trading partner onward on cost (flat tiers versus about $189/mo per partner), when you need healthcare X12 (837/835/270/271), or when you need a REST API, SFTP, or AS2 without upgrading to a separate API product.
© 2026 SignalEDI Inc. All rights reserved.
